Golden Retriever Dog Forums banner

Diamond Naturals or Purina Pro Plan?

44K views 24 replies 16 participants last post by  FurdogDad  
#1 ·
Hello Golden lovers!? My 3 year old Bentley has been on Diamond Naturals since he was a puppy. Our new baby, Bailey...the breeder had her on Purina Pro-Plan All Stages. Anyone have any thoughts on either brand? Bentley is healthy with a gorgeous coat, never any allergies or sickness. The vet seemed to think the Purina Pro-Plan was a good choice.
 
#2 · (Edited)
A lot of members feed PPP, I'm one of them.

If it were me, I'd leave my pup on the PPP for several months before making a change of food if that's what the breeder is feeding.

It'll give your pup time to adjust to his new environment, a change of food could cause an upset tummy until your pup is settled in. After a few months if you want to change, then go ahead.
 
#6 ·
I actually feed both. My goldens are on Pro Plan Performance. I also have 2 mixed breeds on Diamond. My reason for the difference is my goldens are involved in a lot of performance activities, the others are couch potatoes.
 
#7 ·
Diamond has had too many recalls for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rabernet
#9 ·
Pro Plan here, too. I like that it has been around for decades, researched, developed, and tested by animal food scientists, and has never had a recall. So many people in the dog sport and conformation worlds feed it, too. And my dog thrives on it.
 
#17 ·
I don't advocate any of the dog food sites, just those are verifiable recalls. Since it was bullet pointed I just used that. There was also 2007 Pro Plan dry dog food recalls. I was just mentioning this since someone said Pro Plan never had recalls. I wasn't stating PP SSS formula specifically. But Pro Plan has had recalls.


Also, I've been to most of the relevant food companies R&D and manufacturing plants as well. Purina, Iams, Science Diet, Nutro, Diamond, Wellness, Natrua, among a few others.
 
#11 ·
My boy came home from the breeder on PPP Sensitive skin and stomach. She has always used it. It's now 5 years and he's thriving on it. Beautiful soft shiny coat, no hot spots, ears are clean plus he does circles when I go to feed him.
Stools are great, no scooting. I give him 1200 mg. of fish oil daily and a tsp. of coconut oil. I add raw veggies and maybe a cooked egg a few times a week.
 
#13 ·
Well, by definition an all life stage food is technically a small breed puppy food as that is the puppy that has the highest nutritional requirements. The risk there is too much protein and to high a Calcium/Phosphorus ratio. Large breed dogs should be on a large breed puppy food which in lamens terms means a 1.1/1 up to 1.4/1 cal/phos ratio. Small breed puppy foods are usually up to 2/1 ratio. Phosphorus inhibits calcium absorption as a 2/1 ratio means they will grow too fast causing potential joint issues.



Also, Purina and Pro Plan as a line has had recalls in the past as with every major brand of food, Eukanuba, Iams, Nurto, Science Diet among others. Prior to 2011 i do believe there were Pro Plan can foods on recall.




  • In March 2016, Purina issued a voluntary recall for various Pro Plan Savory Meals and Beneful products due to inadequate vitamins and minerals.
  • In August 2013, the FDA issued a recall for Purina ONE Beyond Our White Meat Chicken & Whole Barley Recipe Adult Dry Dog food due to potential salmonella contamination.
  • In May 2012, the FDA issued a recall for Purina Veterinary Diets OM Overweight Management canned cat food due to possible low thiamine levels.
  • In July 2011, Purina issued a voluntary recall for Purina ONE Vibrant Maturity 7+ dry cat food due to potential salmonella contamination.
  • In June 2011, Purina issued a voluntary recall for Purina Cat Chow Naturals due to potential salmonella contamination.
 
#15 ·
Straight from that formidable Food Advisor website authored by a dentist.
PPP SS&S has never had a recall no matter how much the dentist gets a stipend for trashing leading pet foods. I live near a Purina facility and have had privy to unannounced tours. Hospital operating rooms could learn from Purina's controlled facilities.
 
#16 ·
Ah yes, that Food Advisor who gives 5 star ratings to the foods that appear to cause (or contribute to) dilated cardio myopathy in Goldens, and gives poor ratings to the foods that the dogs have thrived on for decades....
 
#18 ·
I feel like every week for the past few months I am meeting people that say they have goldens that are 13 plus years. Just met another this weekend ( an AKC judge that says he has a geriatric wing on his house with dogs 13 and 14 years old ). The next question I ask is, what food do you feed - every time it is Purina Pro Plan.
 
#21 ·
This is nice to hear! We're trying to decide what food to go with for Teddy (he's been on Diamond Naturals LBP, that's what the breeder used). I'm leaning toward transitioning to PPP SSS when we switch to adult food since there are so many people here who love it.
 
#25 ·
Why would someone join the forum and choose to revive a 7 yr old thread about dog food to play the "adopt, don't shop" shame game? I don't think anyone who has purchased(NOT adopted) a dog, either puppy or adult, has anything to be ashamed of. Nor do I think that folks that choose to rehome a dog from an individual/shelter/rescue do......it's a personal choice we all have to make based on what our wants/needs/expectations are of the pet we want to share our homes and lives with. I feel that i have built forum friendships in the 4.5 yrs I've been here with with folks that have taken the rehome route....3goldens, OscarsDad and brianne are a few that come to mind....as well as as many who, like myself and my family, have chosen to purchase dogs from breeders. I respect and support all of these folks equally. I was bullied as a child and have zero tolerance for it. I consider the whole "adopt, don't shop" mantra to be a form of that. I respect however the folks who encourage others to consider that as an option and also make that choice for themselves.