Personally I do. The peanut butter I get for the dogs just contains 1 ingredient: peanuts.

 

I bought a jar of peanut butter for dogs and the ingredient was peanuts. But, I found the peanut butter to be very runny/liquidy. Maybe this was a one-off or is this standard? If so, how do you work with it being so gloopy?

 

You should avoid hydrogenated oils too, not just your pup.

 

Like the others said, it should just have peanuts. Real peanut butter separates, so I shake the container vigorously before opening and then stir. You can also store unopened containers upside down for a little bit to get the oil to move throughout and not just sit on the top.

 

If you want a special time treat for them, I love this company. Like everyone said, I stir up the container and put in the refrigerator. They get a tablespoon of this from time to time in a kong.
Banana Buddy Budder – Bark Bistro (barkbistrocompany.com) Plenty of other flavors too

 

@GoldenDude - I set the jar on top of my espresso machine overnight to warm. In the morning I pour half the oil into a cup, then use a long narrow spoon (the kind used with ice cream sundaes) to work the remaining oil into the peanut butter. Once that’s mixed I add the remainder of the oil and work it in. With warm PB it takes about five minutes. Once mixed it goes in the fridge and it doesn’t separate.

 

Unless you're feeding him a heck of a lot of peanut butter, IMO, the small amount of hydrogenated oil is unlikely to be an issue.

 

I don’t give mine peanut butter enough to worry about the oil. Most important thing to me would be making sure it’s not sugar free.

 

Most important thing to me would be making sure it’s not sugar free.

I think you must mean making sure it doesn't have artificial sweetener in it. That's definitely important, too. But sugar-free is fine.