Golden Retriever Dog Forums banner
Cancel

Which one is your favorite?

  • Total voters
    60
  • Poll closed .

What's your favorite Thanksgiving Pie?

1749 Views 29 Replies 28 Participants Last post by  Merlins mom, 
Griffyn'sMom
My son needs 50 tallies for a school project. I hope you all can help him. Thanks in advance! :p:

Poll will close on or about Friday when his numbers are due.
Reply
Save
Like
1 - 20 of 30 Posts
Augustus McCrae's Mom
May not exactly be Thanksgiving, but apple.
Reply
Save
Like
B
apple out of those choices...actually, probably apple out of any choices.
Reply
Save
Like
paula bedard
I'm kinda surprised that pumpkin isn't higher in the rankings. My favorite is actually an Apple/Cranberry pie and I only make them during the Holidays...but I voted for pumpkin. It's a Holiday comfort food for hubby, he loves it.
Reply
Save
Like
gold'nchocolate
Count me in for Pumpkin pie!!! My next favorite would be apple pie with a side of Vanilla ice cream.
Reply
Save
Like
solinvictus
Pumpkin is my all time favorite. But I wouldn't turn down Banana Cream or Chocolate.

Everyone else here loves Apple Pies. So, the rule is the first pie of the fall season at this house has to be apple. :)
Reply
Save
Like
amy22
Chocolate Cream Pie is my ALL time favorite..but I like most pies...I voted for Blueberry ;)
Reply
Save
Like
rappwizard
Voted pumpkin but if someone offered me a sweet potato pie, I sure would grab a fork and start pile driving away!
Reply
Save
Like
LibertyME
APPLE APPLE APPLE!
Followed by Chocolate Cream with cooked filling not the instant stuff!
Reply
Save
Like
Oaklys Dad
I voted pumpkin but if you set a pecan pie beside it I would be all over the pecan pie.
Reply
Save
Like
docinbird
What? No choice for pecan pie? Last year, a friend made a very good compromise pie. It was an apple pie without the top crust with pumpkin filling over that. It was very good. Plus, it solved the problem of everyone saying they would like a small slice of each.
Reply
Save
Like
Miss Happy
I voted for coconut cream...I have my Mother's recipe and it is delicious.
Reply
Save
Like
desilu
I agree with Oakley's Dad - pecan! Yummm . . . then pumpkin as second choice. Okay, who am I kidding - I'll take a slice of each!

Miss Happy said:
I voted for coconut cream...I have my Mother's recipe and it is delicious.
Click to expand...
Any chance you'd share the recipe? I love coconut cream pie - but not for Thanksgiving. Gotta have the traditional then!
Reply
Save
Like
Griffyn'sMom
docinbird said:
What? No choice for pecan pie? Last year, a friend made a very good compromise pie. It was an apple pie without the top crust with pumpkin filling over that. It was very good. Plus, it solved the problem of everyone saying they would like a small slice of each.
Click to expand...
:hide:
I didn't make the list. I think the Teacher and the kids made it.
:curtain:​
Reply
Save
Like
coppers-mom
Chocolate!
Pecan!
Okay, I'll vote for one on the list, but I don't really like those.
Reply
Save
Like
redhare
MMMMMM.....pie! I picked pumpkin, but it really ties with apple, and if pecan is there it wins hands down. Quite honestly, any sweet pie is my favorite!
Reply
Save
Like
missmarstar
I don't discriminate.. on Thanksgiving I have a piece of EVERY pie available. ;)


Though when I think of Thanksgiving I immediately think pumpkin pie.. so that's the one I chose. :)
Reply
Save
Like
FlyingQuizini
There was no choice for "other" so I voted pumpkin... but my REAL fave is choco chip pumpkin cheesecake!
Reply
Save
Like
lgnutah
Is it too late to add pecan pie? That's a standard at our house
Reply
Save
Like
DNL2448
My favorite of all time including Thanksgiving, is strawberry/rhubarb. Not one of the choices, but my second favorite is pumpkin.
Reply
Save
Like
1 - 20 of 30 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Golden Retriever Dog Forums
A forum community dedicated to Golden Retriever owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about breeds, training, puppies, food reviews, service animals, and more.
Full Forum Listing
Explore Our Forums
Golden Retrievers Main Discussion Golden Retriever Puppy (up to 1 year) Golden Retriever Pictures Golden Retriever Health, Anatomy & Breed Standard Choosing A Golden Retriever Breeder & Puppy
Top