She barks even with the collar on! Pretty sure they don't mind because each and every one of them has at least one dog that does the same thing! At least Ruby has never broken out of a crate to get to the action (she doesn't even try that).Now ---- I think it's odd that you have a confessed crate barker/screamer and have "given up" on it --- but yet you're asking about the bark collar for the puppy? Why doesn't the older nuisance barker have one on?????? Barking in the crate is a HUGE pet peeve of mine --- you are lucky she is quiet at a test, and I bet if you really asked your training buddies, they DO care and are quite annoyed with your dog carrying on.
Put a bark collar on the barking dogs and everyone is happy.
Best of luck. What breeding is your pup from? Topbrass has FT breedings and FT/show crosses, so there could be a big difference in temperament from one litter to the other. If you bought from a pure FT litter then I guess you know you're asking for reactive and impulsive! I need something less keyed up than that!
Piper is Kuventre You Were Born TaFly MH X Topbrass Drake MH**. Very similar breeding to Ruby (Drake is Ruby's 1/2 brother and Sarah is Ruby's aunt). She was the pick performance female of the litter (as was Ruby) so, yes, I do know I was asking for reactive and implusive! Careful what you ask for!